Jamie Carragher disagrees with Ben Mee over controversial moment during Leeds United vs Liverpool

Ben Mee and Jamie Carragher have had their say on the controversial moment during Leeds United’s heavy defeat to Liverpool.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

The Sky Sports pundits have been having their say on a controversial moment during Leeds United’s heavy home defeat to Liverpool.

It was a night to forget for the Whites, who lost 6-1 to Jurgen Klopp’s men, officially becoming the worst defence in the Premier League this season. The Reds put on a dominant display, but Javi Gracia’s men were sloppy defensively and they paid the price for their sub-par display.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Though, Liverpool were helped on their way. Cody Gakpo put Liverpool ahead after 35 minutes, and during the build-up to the goal, Trent Alexander-Arnold appeared to control the ball with his arm. VAR reviewed the incident, but the goal was allowed to stand.

Sky Sports’ guest presenter and Brentford star Ben Mee said of the incident: “Looking at it initially, I thought it was handball. His arm is by his side, but then you look at the replay and he moves his arm. I think it's handball. You see it slow motion and the movement towards the ball, I think it's handball.”

Perhaps unsurprisingly, former Liverpool defender Carragher saw reason in the final decision, adding: “I think there is doubt, no doubt. For me, when it hits him, it looks like his hand is sticking out.

“Even before (Junior) Firpo does anything, he has got himself ready, almost where you think the ball might hit you, and when you look at his arm there, his arm is already in that position. There is no doubt it moves out, it's whether that's because the ball is there or whether it's naturally where his arm was going to go. I think it could have could have gone either way. No doubt about that.”

Ultimately, Leeds went on to score one and concede five more, so while Liverpool were helped in finding the opener, this never looked like a night where Leeds were going to pick up a point or more.

Comment Guidelines

National World encourages reader discussion on our stories. User feedback, insights and back-and-forth exchanges add a rich layer of context to reporting. Please review our Community Guidelines before commenting.