Leeds Rhinos v Hull KR talking points: Ash Handley's on song, class act Alfie Edgell, another prop needed

Leeds Rhinos have a 50 per cent record going into Betfred Super League round three, following Thursday’s 22-12 defeat at Hull KR.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

Rhinos were the better side for much of a tough game, on a heavy pitch, but ill-discipline eventually took its toll as two yellow cards and an 11-3 penalty count in the hosts’ favour wore them down. Here’s five talking points.

1: Ash Handley seems to be involved in his own, one-man try of the season competition. The first of his two touchdowns in the win over Salford Red Devils was a belter, but he matched it against the Robins with another sensational effort. Much of the credit goes to Brodie Croft for his vision to spot the compressed defence and kick, early in the count, for Handley from near Leeds’ line. The winger read it to perfection, displayed impressive pace and his dummy and swerve past the full-back put icing on the cake. Handley is an outstanding finisher, but his strong carries are also hugely important for Rhinos. England are blessed with good wingers and the Leeds man is right up there.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

2: Rhinos have had to field a rookie full-back in successive visits to Hull KR. Nineteen-year-old Alfie Edgell didn’t face the conditions - or aerial threat - Luke Hooley endured last March, but it was a remarkably assured full debut for someone who was an injury doubt the previous day and only found out he was playing an hour before kick-off.

Ash Handley touches down for a stunning try in Leeds Rhinos' defeat at Hull KR. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com.Ash Handley touches down for a stunning try in Leeds Rhinos' defeat at Hull KR. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com.
Ash Handley touches down for a stunning try in Leeds Rhinos' defeat at Hull KR. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com.

Obviously, Hull KR targeted him and he did make one mistake, but he contributed some fine catches and his positional play, reading of the game and willingness to put his body on the line were top-class. Lachie Miller, who dropped out because of illness, will remain Rhinos’ first-choice full back at the moment, but Edgell is clearly a player with a big future.

3: It will be an anxious wait for Rhinos until the match review panel announce charges from round two. Having been without their both first-choice props, the last thing Leeds needed was two of their substitute ‘middles’ to get sin-binned, but that’s the nature of the game this year.

As Paul Momirovski was the previous week, Sam Lisone appeared to be harshly treated when he was shown a yellow card on the advice of video referee Ben Thaler. In the current climate, James Donaldson’s tackle might have resulted in a red card and he will be charged, but Leeds’ number 25 is probably the least malicious player in the entire sport and his good record - and the lack of force involved - should mean a low grade. Hull KR also had Peta Hiku sin-binned so that’s six cards in Leeds’ two games this season.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

4: A big debate in pre-season was over whether Leeds’ squad was light by one big front-rower. Having seen Zane Tetevano and Sam Walters depart, Rhinos signed one prop in Kieran Hudson - who has yet to make his Super League debut - and added another, youngster Tom Nicholson-Watton, to the group from the reserves.

Leeds Rhinos youngster Alfie Edgell is consoled by James Bentley after Hull KR's final try. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com.Leeds Rhinos youngster Alfie Edgell is consoled by James Bentley after Hull KR's final try. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com.
Leeds Rhinos youngster Alfie Edgell is consoled by James Bentley after Hull KR's final try. Picture by Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com.

Otherwise, priority was given to the spine as a full-back, two halves and a hooker were brought in. That will pay off as the players get more time together on the field, but just two games in, Leeds do look light up front.

Read More
Read more: Ex-Leeds Rhinos Zane Tetevano star set for shock NRL return with Cant...

For a spell in the first half at Hull KR, Donaldson and Mickael Goudemand were Rhinos’ props. They are two of the hardest-working players in Super League, but physically among the smallest. If they can’t bring someone in, Leeds need Mikolaj Oledzki and Tom Holroyd back on the field as soon as possible and for them to stay injury-free for the rest of the year.

5: If Rhinos lose to Catalans they will be on the same points tally after round three as they were last year, but - accepting there’s much room for improvement - the early indications are this is a better team.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad
Leeds Rhinos' James Donaldson is sin-binned by referee Jack Smith during the defeat at Hull KR. Picture by Jonathan Gawthorpe.Leeds Rhinos' James Donaldson is sin-binned by referee Jack Smith during the defeat at Hull KR. Picture by Jonathan Gawthorpe.
Leeds Rhinos' James Donaldson is sin-binned by referee Jack Smith during the defeat at Hull KR. Picture by Jonathan Gawthorpe.

Though the loss at Hull KR was disappointing, Leeds were the better team for much of the game. Their defence was strong, all three of their hosts’ tries coming from kicks and they are clearly working together as a team. Conditions play a big part at this time of the year, but the combination between Croft and Matt Frawley has shown some good signs and the outside-backs are scoring tries - four of the five so far. Leeds need to do more with the ball, but performance-wise there have been more positives than negatives so far.