Graham Smyth's Leeds United player ratings vs Birmingham with 2/10 'debut to forget' but pair of 8s

Leeds United needed 120 minutes and penalties to book their place in the FA Cup fifth round at Birmingham.

Leeds United booked their place in the FA Cup fifth round following a 1-1 draw and penalty-shootout victory at Birmingham City. Lukas Nmecha scored the Whites’ only goal in normal time but a perfect spot-kick showing got the Premier League team’s job done.

A much-changed Leeds side rode their luck in the first half before going ahead early in the second, Nmecha arrowing a finish in at Ryan Allsop’s near-post against the run of play. Birmingham kept up the pressure and got their reward late on, however, through substitute Patrick Roberts’ late deflected strike.

The game became stretched in added-time as both teams tired and neither were able to grab a winner, with chances wasted at either end. Leeds then scored four penalties from four as misses from Tommy Doyle and Roberts allowed Sean Longstaff to send his side into the FA Cup fifth round.

YEP chief football writer Graham Smyth was at St Andrew’s to watch the action. Here are his Leeds United player ratings...

Celebrating 135 years of telling Leeds' stories
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice