From hidden back-street gems to the legendary butchers who have been feeding our city for generations, the passion for a perfect crust is clearly alive and well.
Whether it’s a classic pork pie for a Saturday match, a rich steak and ale to warm up a rainy Monday, or a modern gourmet take on the humble classic, you’ve pinpointed the absolute best of the best.
After sifting through hundreds of your nominations, including many we received through the Yorkshire Evening Post Facebook page, we’ve whittled it down to the top 11.
If you call yourself a pie lover and haven't ticked these off your list yet, you might have some dances left on your dance card for a trip to one of these reader-approved establishments.
7. Haggarts Butchers
Technically just over the border in Birstall, but so many of you nominated them that they had to make the list. Known for their "simply the best" pork pies, they are clearly worth the short drive from Leeds. 🥧 Address: 77 Low Lane, Birstall, Batley, WF17 9EY | Google Street View
8. The Rhubarb Triangle Farm Shop
Located in the heart of the historic Rhubarb Triangle, this farm shop's steak pie was described as "literally the winner, no competition." It’s a favourite for those who value farm-to-table quality. 🥧 Address: Green End Farm, Carlton, Wakefield, WF3 3QR | Contributed
9. Howgate & Farrar
A Woodlesford staple that many readers said "can't be beaten by a mile." Their pies are a hit with the South Leeds community, praised for their high-quality meat and consistent bake. 🥧 Address: 109 Aberford Road, Woodlesford, Leeds, LS26 8LQ | Google Street View
10. Tracey’s Kitchen
Another Pudsey favourite (we told you it was the pie capital), Tracey’s is beloved for its homemade feel and friendly service. Their pork pies were singled out as some of the best in the city. 🥧 Address: 66 Lowtown, Pudsey, LS28 7AA | Google Street View
11. Finer Pleasures
For the gourmet pie lover, many readers pointed towards Josh Whitehead’s creations. Described as "off the chain" and the work of a "culinary genius," these are for when you want a pie that’s a bit more elevated. 🥧 Address: Primarily available via pop-ups and specialised orders (Check their socials for the latest Leeds locations) | Bruce Rollinson