Gig review: Courtney Barnett at The Duchess, York

Courtney Barnett
Courtney Barnett
Have your say

Courtney Barnett is gearing up to be one of the quiet success stories of the year.

The Melbourne based singer-songwriter has been on a roll since releasing a compilation, The Double EP: A Sea Of Split Peas, last October and has since been generating a buzz at a series of live dates.

Her studio recordings pitch her as an anti-folk cousin of Jeffrey Lewis, the tracks being built around rambling comic narratives that detail everyday life events such as panic attacks and masturbation. Live, however, her two-piece backing band lend her a slacker quality that only sometimes hits home.

Opening track ‘David’ is a tight glam-rock stomp that sees her shaking her mop of dark hair and guitar head, part Pavement and part Joan Jett, while ‘Out Of The Woodwork’ has a gentle country rock vibe. Its arrangements are effectively a bed for her deadpan lyrics and the notion of a prose poem being given musical accompaniment is furthered on her solo encore of new track ‘Depreston’.

Basing songs around lyrics rather than structured melody lines nonetheless becomes a problem when they’re suddenly given full bloodied backing from bassist Bones Sloane and drummer Dave Mundie. ‘Lance Jnr’ and ‘Are You Looking After Yourself?’, for instance, both lack a strong enough hook to survive when her vocals have to struggle to be heard over the meandering garage rock.

It’s this uncertainty over whether to offer coffee shop alt-folk narratives or slacker-grunge that makes Barnett such a frustrating talent. ‘History Eraser’ is currently the closest she comes to a compromise between the two, with Sloane chanting the title as an off-kilter chorus while Barnett wrings out lead guitar.

A few more tracks like this and she might truly warrant the early acclaim.

Gig date: May 14

Leeds-bound Paul Weller

Weller, Weller, Weller ... tell me more!