'It is unacceptable that she risked people's safety': Morley woman ordered to pay £12,000 for operating as an unregistered carer

Beverley Bevis was fined £1,500 at Leeds Magistrates' Court today (January 7).

She was also ordered to pay £10,380.91 costs and a £170 victim surcharge as a result of the prosecution brought by the Care Quality Commission (CQC).

Prior to her sentencing, Bevis pleaded guilty to providing a regulated activity – personal care – in people’s own homes through her company, Five Star Homecare Leeds Ltd, without CQC registration. This is a criminal offence.

Personal care includes assisting people to eat and drink, dress, bathe and use the toilet.

CQC brought the prosecution after it received feedback, in September 2018, from a relative of a person who used Five Star Homecare.

At this time, Mrs Bevis had not registered Five Star Homecare with CQC.

This prompted CQC to begin investigating the company, and inspectors visited its Morley premises, unannounced, three weeks later, in October 2018.

Inspectors also found evidence that the company had 23 staff providing personal care to at least seven people.

They also saw staff time sheets and invoices demonstrating that it had been operating illegally.

In April 2020, Five Star Homecare successfully applied for CQC registration – following a robust process – meaning it can now provide a lawful service.

The service was inspected in November 2020 and was given a Requires Improvement rating.

CQC continues to monitor it, including through future inspections, to ensure people’s safety.

Although CQC understands that Mrs Bevis retains involvement with the company, she is not responsible for supervising its regulated activity.

“The registration process is important to appropriately assess services before they care for people.

"Services are then monitored and inspected to ensure that they continue to meet standards that people should be able to expect.

“Unregistered services operate without oversight, putting people at risk of harm.

“Monitoring of domiciliary care agencies is especially important, as people who receive care in their own homes can be particularly vulnerable because of their circumstances.

“When we find providers operating illegally, we do not hesitate to act to protect people.”