Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Trade Window Sales
Sponsored by
For quality conservatories, windows & doors at affordable prices
Over 17,000 satisfied customers in the last 10 years
 
 
Tuesday, 2nd December 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the n/a site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

New shifts hit W Yorks police morale



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
07 October 2008
New police shifts have led to an increase in sick leave, dangerous fatigue and falling morale in the West Yorkshire force, it has been claimed.
Officers have told the YEP there is widespread unrest over the new shifts for 5,000 officers introduced by Chief Constable Sir Norman Bettison.

They say they now work fewer hours daily but their numbers of days off have been cut. Officers are now warning they may withdraw from the agreement. They talked of:

  • Tired colleagues rejecting jobs over their radios with the claims "not in my remit";

  • Some police being at risk of falling asleep at the wheel;

  • The children of two officers "never seeing mum and dad together";

  • Domestic relationships breaking down;

  • Officers "transferring" to other forces, "changing working roles or going sick" to cope with childcare changes


  • A leaked report to West Yorkshire Police Federation members, shows that between April and August, 16,000 extra hours were lost to sickness – a 3.4 per cent rise compared to 2007.

    The report, written by federation chairman, Tom McGhie, reveals officers describing:
  • feeling tired all the time";

  • 4pm to 2am weekend shifts routinely retained for overtime;

  • sergeants regularly removed from Neighbourhood Policing Teams to cover for sickness, custody duties and emergency reserve units;

  • officers feeling their lives consist only of work or preparing for work;

  • difficulties scheduling holidays;

  • short notice in duty changes.


  • Some federation representatives now want to return to an eight-hour shift system.

    The previous "six days on four off" pattern was introduced after the historic three eight-hour round the clock shift system was judged bad for officers' long-term health

    Mr McGhie said: "There is no doubt that the changes have had a serious effect on the family life of a large number of officers. We are trying to get the best outcome."

    A West Yorkshire Police spokesman said: "People regularly tell us they want a more visible police presence on their street, working at local level to tackle local problems.

    "Neighbourhood Policing does that, and the new shift
    patterns allow us to provide the necessary cover at the times of greatest need."

    He added: "Any change is difficult but we have worked hard to minimise the impact on officers' personal lives, while still providing the services the public expect and need.

    "We only have so many officers and these shift patterns maximise the benefits for the public.

    "In general, staff and officers working shifts in a 24-hour role in West Yorkshire Police still receive 141 rest days a year (most people get 104), in addition to annual leave and public holidays. The sickness rise reflects a longer term national trend which pre-dates these changes."

    The full article contains 455 words and appears in n/a newspaper.
    Page 1 of 1

    • Last Updated: 07 October 2008 9:56 AM
    • Source: n/a
    • Location: Leeds
     
    Prev
    1
    Next
    1

    Concerned Member of the public,

    Leeds 07/10/2008 10:59:53
    Police Officers regularly place their health on the line to protect us. They work nights and very unsociable hours. The Chief and his staff must remember that they are not robots; they do need to eat and sleep. They get tired and this affects their health, safety and ability to do their job. I know several Officers who have complained about the negative effects of his enforced shift change. I have not seen any increase in policing my neighbourhood. So tell me where are the benefits. If sickness is up (I recall in a previous article that sickness had been falling for 5 years) then we are still short of frontline police. I have seen local NPT at work at 3am on a weekend, but tell me how that benefits the community. They should be at work when they can deal with community issues not dealing with drunks in Headingley. As a family man, it would hurt me terribly if my child said he didn’t see mum and dad together and this comment alone should cause Mr Bettison to re-visit his policy on these shifts.
    It wasn’t broke so why oh why fix it.
    Will it take a tired and stressed Officer to have a tragic accident coming to or leaving work because they are so exhausted to make him sit up and take heed.
    I want the Police. We need the Police. We want a motivated, relaxed, stress free Police force that are happy and content in their jobs as this will lead to a professional service that serves us properly.
    The Government refuse to pay them a deserved wage and now their own Chief causes them further distress.
    2

    Frustrated Worker,

    07/10/2008 11:58:54
    I myself am a serving officer in Leeds and have been for several years - all of which were spent on the 'old' shift system of 6 on 4 off - until this year.

    To cope with the demands or rather making an impact as the new CC, there are now different patterns dependant on what you work, I personally work a pattern on 7 on 3 off 7 on 4 off.

    Every colleague I have spoken to is suffering the same effects and as both a resident in West Yorks and a Police Officer the consequences of the shift changes are frightening - constant tiredness, lack of interest in doing the job and a growing anger and temptation of finding other work.

    I can say hand on heart that peoples home life, marriages and children are been effected, I hardly see my kids during the week and miss out on the basics. I wonder if the Chief Constable will foot officer's legal bills when the prospects of divorce loom.

    Look at the facts, an increase of 16,000 hours in sickness in such a short space of time - in real terms that is one police officer having TWO years off constantly because of sickness - however, this is not spread across two years, its spread across months.

    Prior to the shift changes, which were fought by the Federation, everything was working fine, crime rates were falling, sickness was at it's lowest ever, morale was high (which is essential given the job we do and the things we see) and each and every officer was proud to do the job to the best of their abilities.

    Surely the Police Authority must sit up and take notice of what is happening and take some form of action - if not just for the officers and staff - but for the people of West Yorkshire that depend on the Police been there in any event.
    3

    cloak&dagger,

    07/10/2008 18:48:42
    I finished 2 early Sat and Sun shifts starting at 07:00hrs and finishing at 17:00hrs both days, which I know is fine.
    The problem is your body is set to getting up at 06:00 hours and going to sleep at normal times only to then go to work on Monday and Tuesday (tonight) at 22:00 hrs untill 07:00 hrs!!!!! My body clock is all over the place, I found myself dangerously tired at 05:00 hrs this morning and still required to drive a Police car to emergencies.
    Somebody is going to get killed or seriously hurt due to the dangerous fatigue of an officer, be it PC or Joe Public.
    This is only ONE example, the list is long.
    I also see very little of my young family and is putting a strain on MY relationship.
    The only point I want to clarify is that one of 'Not in my remit. This does not apply to your response officer who will turn out to your 999 call or the majority of other reported crime.
    Response officers do not have a remit and WILL attend jobs they are sent to because of the nature of the job we do. The Response officers on a team are short of numbers but are increasingly asked to cover nearly every other department in the division I work in.
    Amazingly we could still work the new hours that the Chief wants us to work to cover the so called peak times on our old 6 on 4 off shift pattern, but point blankly refuses to do so without giving any valid reason.
    I can only hope our, sorry your, Chief Constable aknowledges the detrimental effect the shift patterns are having on his staff and the public we serve. Failing that the Police authority step in and sort the problem.
    4

    cloak&dagger,

    07/10/2008 18:55:02
    P.S. Who is the Police Spokesperson?
    Have they worked the 10 week rolling shift pattern and have the felt the effect of the shifts on them and there family? Or was it a civilian officer on a 9-5, Monday to Friday shift pattern, please enlighten us?
    Also the NPT shift patterns are reasonable and is not the main concern, it is the Response shift patterns. And I hear you say, if the NPT shifts are not that bad then why don't you work them? I will be very soon moving to them, but if everyone did that you won't have any response officers and they are the ones that work 24/7 and attend the emergency jobs. I like serving the public in my current role but where do I place my allegiance? Family or job?
    5

    Mr Concerned of Leeds,

    08/10/2008 17:01:22
    Funny how they dont seem too tired come matchday at elland road, the more the merrier, not one of them gets paid overtime though. No but everyone covering their normal shift does.

    the job of the police is to work unsociable hours and to police in unsociable areas something they seem to have forgotten a long time ago.

    Its about time they concentrated on their jobs instead of petty crusades against motorists and football fans and got back to doing what we all want them to do, making our streets safer and attending crime scenes when we have been the victims of crime.

    Once they do that I'll have a lot more sympathy for them.

    6

    Coppers Are Human Too,

    Leeds 08/10/2008 19:31:27
    I am shocked at the comments made by Mr Concerned of Leeds. Yes there are a lot of police officers on match day but they are not paid overtime, well at least my husband hasn't been when he has worked a match.

    I can't beleive that people still think that police should stop complaining and get on with dealing with real crime. My husband has dealt with murders, rape, muggings, theft, shall I continue? Is that "concentrating" on their jobs enough for you?

    Yes they know what the hours they will be working when they join and they accept that and as heir families so do we but my son can go almost 2 weeks without seeing his dad due to the shift patterns, is that right?

    Mr Bettison states he is all for a balance of work and family but I don't see it.

    It's about time we praised them for putting their lives on the line. I couldn't do that job, could you?
    7

    Officers Wife,

    Wharfedale 08/10/2008 22:58:11
    I too would like to know details of the consultation they conducted with officers and their families because I've yet to meet anyone that was consulted. My husband & I have a young baby, and now that I have returned to work we have just 3 days every 3 weeks as a family since the shift change. The hardest thing is that I become sole carer for our child most of the time who is missing out on valuable time with his father. The new shift pattern means most officers, my husband included now work 2 in 3 weekends in addition to working 7 days without a break, often doing crazy amounts of overtime in that period. I am not part of the police force, I just happened to marry a serving officer so whilst I can see that it's difficult for people to understand their current plight I agree with previous comments that they're not robots and this situation can't carry on without there being damage to families across West Yorkshire. I'd love to know if Norman Bettison and his management team work many weekends. I think I already know the answer to that one!
    8

    Sadie Prince,

    30/10/2008 23:54:08
    There was no 'consultation'. What this force calls consultation is telling you what they are going to do then threatening you with draconian measures if you don't go along with it.

    None of the arguements put forward by the Chief for changing the rota were valid. The old shift system met everyones needs and was better for officers. Mr Concerned will be pleased to know that even under the old shift system we worked unsociable hours but they were structured in a way that allowed us some usuable family time. I am sure he/she does not begrudge us that. Perhaps Mr Concerned would like to work some of the 4pm - 2am shifts when officers are often kept on until 7am due to there not being enough Response Officers. Again due to Mr Bettisons' vision. We get the same number of days off under this new rota as we did before that isn't the problem. Its the ridiculous way the shifts are configured. You don't get any more Bobbies on the beat at key times. Basically the Chief changed the shifts because he could there is no other reason. He lost the first vote and boy was he mad. The only reason the new shifts came in was because he threatened us with an awful 8 hour rota which would have meant officers working over every day.

    What Mr Concerned needs to remember is that we cannot say no to overtime and believe you me after 10hrs of answering calls with no break (Yes we seldom get meal breaks )the last thing you want to do is work overtime. We also get our days off cancelled and our shifts changed at short notice. We get treated like rubbish by certain members of the public. But the majority of us turn up everyday early for work, whether we are ill or not. Did I also mention that we don't get paid for the first half hour of any overtime.
    Prev
    1
    Next

     

    Comment on this Story

     

    In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

     
     
     
      

     
     


    Sister Newspapers:
    Press Complaints Commission

    This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

    If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.