Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Trade Window Sales
Sponsored by
For quality conservatories, windows & doors at affordable prices
Over 17,000 satisfied customers in the last 10 years
 
 
Sunday, 5th July 2009

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the n/a site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Leeds United: McAllister's earned some breathing space



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
02 December 2008
Three weeks ago, Gary McAllister was asked for his reaction to the news that Huddersfield Town and Carlisle United had dispensed with their managers.
"Unfortunately this is part of the job," he said. "The one certainty is that you're going to get sacked."

It is the mantra of every football manager and the condition under which they agree to employment. Stan Ternent and John Ward lost control of
their clubs so their clubs exercised the right to take extreme action.

A change of manager is not a guaranteed solution to ailing form, but it is so often the result.

Leeds United are unlikely to jump to that conclusion while the dust settles on their defeat at Histon, but the board at Elland Road cannot be oblivious to the sound of their manager's position being critically examined.

HAVE YOUR SAY AND HEAR THE VIEWS OF PHIL HAY AND ANDREW HUTCHINSON IN OUR WEEKLY LIVE LEEDS UNITED WEBCHAT - EVERY WEDNESDAY 1-2PM. SET A REMINDER BY GOING TO THE WEBCHAT PAGE NOW.

It was ridiculous to think that, having commented on Ward and Ternent, McAllister would be addressing doubts about his own credentials less than a month later.

That was the reality on Sunday afternoon as, in a cramped press room beneath Histon's main stand, he looked the question in the eye and stated that, yes, he was still the right candidate for the job at Elland Road.

McAllister was bound to say that, but it was essential he did.

The loss to Histon was a humiliation for a man who prides himself on maximising the talent of his squad, but it was not the final straw for his tenure. Far from it.

More troubling than the question itself would have been any sign in McAllister's answers of personal uncertainty about his ability to achieve at Leeds United what he promised he would.

Yet the pressure being placed on him by sections of United's support is justified to a large degree. He must see that himself.

McAllister set out in pursuit of automatic promotion this season, but his team lie seventh in League One. He put a high value on a place in the third round of the FA Cup but saw it sacrificed against a Blue Square Premier club, the likes of which Leeds have never lost to before.

His defence is fragile and the club's results away from home during the past two months have been unspeakably poor. To say otherwise would be a distortion of the truth.

These are honest criticisms of a manager and his squad, and criticisms that can be made of every club in the country from time to time.



The full article contains 451 words and appears in n/a newspaper.
Page 1 of 4

  • Last Updated: 03 December 2008 8:27 AM
  • Source: n/a
  • Location: Leeds
 
Prev
1
Next
1

michael forster,

Batley 02/12/2008 16:58:52
I admire your attempts to defend Macca because he is a great guy and everyone would like him to succeed but your reasoning is flawed.

To emphasise the clubs league position and claim it does Macca credit does not take into account the clubs resources; with the talent available it is hard to imagine them in a worse league position.

A more accurate way of assessing their position is to look at the authority of their performance; in that respect Macca does not look good.

They have lost too often and when they have won they have often been unconvincing. The 5-2 beating of Northampton saw them failing to control the game or keep posession and they could have conceded six so when they lost the league match it was not a surprise.

A teams defence is the basis of success and the Leeds defence is woefull. He can't decide who is his best keeper which doesn't help the defence settle and the positive reults have been achieved despite a seive-like defence and with a reliance on the individual brilliance of a handfull of players who keep producing despite a lack of teamwork.
2

Barry Cooper,

Clevedon 02/12/2008 17:17:14
I think this is a balanced and reasonable summary of the task facing Macca and his team. But, I agree with Michael, with over 40 years of following The Whites I, like most fans, find it really difficult to watch a team performance that is so inconsistent. The first 45 minutes at Northampton were the worst I have seen for a long time. It was all different in the second half but by then we were the obligatory goal down. Despite all that good second half work nobody was surprised to see us concede late in the game to lose the match.

Its essential that we find some steel and organisation in defence. A central defenders job isn't that difficult when high balls come into our box - the job is to get your head there first and get it away. Get back to basics and we woudn't have conceded most of the last goals we've given away. A passing game is great to watch - but at Histon?? we have to increase the range of styles available for different teams and different conditions.

Its not a crisis yet but we need to still be in touch by the time the Jan transfer window opens
3

Pompeywhite,

02/12/2008 17:59:25
When you state:- "It would also be virtually unprecedented – unacceptable, even – for a club to rule that seventh place at the start of December was grounds to hand their manager his P45" Weren't we only about 10th? in October in the Championship when Bates sacked Blackwell in favour of Wise, who did take us down to our lowest level ever! not content with that, we cant beat a pub team, how low will we go?
4

Chareose,

Fareham 02/12/2008 20:24:40
A good summery. Macca feels so right as Leeds manager. He understands the pain the fans have gone through throughout Leeds history and he knows what makes the club tick. He was undeniably an intelligent player and handles himself with a quiet dignity as our manager. I felt when he took over that we could only benefit from his involvement and we have. Our kids are blossoming and at times our team plays sublime football.
On Sunday he made a tactical mistake in not playing long ball and generally our defence looks shakey. But despite this Macca more than deserves a proper chance to sort it out, he deserves our complete backing ! Something hes unlikely to get from the secion of my fellow leeds supporters that suffer from IQ problems.
Macca is sill learning, i hope he can become the manager i stil beleive he can become at Leeds United !

Lets give Macca our backing !
5

MSKA,

London 04/12/2008 09:59:59
A well balanced and well written article. I am one of the so called "minority" calling for action and change. I find myself agreeing with Mr Forster again - this club has the resources and facilities to make automatic promotion - seventh place is just not good enough!!! If that gap is not narrowed in the next few weeks I predict we will be fighting just to make the play-offs - and as we know the play-offs are a lottery!!! As for the attractive football argument - I dont buy it. I am sure Leeds United fans will forsake that for promotion out of a division which is not renowned for its attractive football. Come on lets get real - Leeds United are marking time in this division - they dont belong there. Unless Mr Hay you are becoming like many Leeds fans who seem to be accepting the new found status in the lower echelons. Many of us who have supported the club since the sixties - categorically do not accept our current position. Its just not good enough. Lets all wake up and smell reality - what do we want??? Then how do we achieve it?? Back to Mcallister - lets see what happens in the next few weeks!!!
Prev
1
Next

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.